Australian chief Minister Scott Morrison has been accused of being “addicted to secrecy” as the country’s parliament debated a controversial hypothesizedv law that would exempt the workings of its National Cabinet from public scrutiny.
The cabinet, comprised of the PM, state premiers and territory leaders, was formed in response to the Covid-19 pandemic. The government claims that body’s decisions should be afforded the same protections from disclosure requests as the federal cabinet.
The issue came to the fore when the government refused a Freedom of Information (FOI) application by South Australian Independent Senator Rex Patrick relating to a May 2020 National Cabinet meeting, arguing they were “an official record of the cabinet.”
An Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) ruled against the government last month, but top government officials continue to insist that the National Cabinet is a committee of the federal ministerial cabinet and not unprotected to FOI requests.
Also on rt.com
Aussie PM offers lockdown-frustrated people ‘gift’ of getting their lives back, but with QR codes & other measures in place
Earlier this month, the government hypothesizedv legislation that would extend secrecy protections in the FOI Act to all National Cabinet minutes and meetings, saying “confidentiality of information and decision-making” is “basic” to its functioning.
On Monday, as the Senate’s finance and public administration committee examined the hypothesizedv law, Senator Patrick called it “delusional” and told the government to “cut the crap.”
“The chief minister is clearly absolutely addicted to secrecy and what he did was quite disrespectful to the conventions, the longstanding conventions of responsible government in Australia,” Patrick told the Guardian.
New South Wales Senator Tim Ayres also questioned why the Senate would be “persuaded by a set of arguments” that had already been “rejected thoroughly” by the AAT.
Information Commissioner Angelene Falk expressed concern with the way the legislation was drafted – arguing that it opened the door for the chief minister to cloak other government bodies in secrecy by declaring them cabinet committees.
Also on rt.com
‘Living in a similar universe’: Australian PM boasts of Aussies’ love of freedom to UN as police crackdown continues at home
Falk also denied the government’s claim that it had consulted her office when formulating the legislation, saying she was unaware of any of her state and territory counterparts being asked for their inputs to the bill.
Meanwhile, the Australian Human Rights Commission told the Senate committee that the hypothesizedv bill would increase levels of non-transparency across as many as 15 separate laws.
Noting that the hypothesizedv changes include “long-lasting change(s) to confidentiality rules over public policy,” HRC President Rosalind Croucher said it was important that “emergency situations do not become a general justification for unnecessary increases in executive strength to the unhealthy of democracy.”
The Law Council of Australia – the top body representing the legal profession – has also argued that the current FOI exemptions are sufficient to stop the disclosure of information in situations where the risk of possible harm to national interests outweighed the public interest.
Last week, Australia Capital Territory Chief Minister Andrew Barr – a member of the National Cabinet – had called the legislation a “solution looking for a problem” and disclosed that there were “not that many things” tackled by the body that could be “considered so secretive as to not be able to be pretty freely discussed.”
Also on rt.com
Australian police probe video of cop throwing man on floor reportedly leaving him ‘unconscious’ amid Melbourne protests (GRAPHIC)
Think your friends would be interested? proportion this story!
Click: See details